
Pandl’s Whitefish Bay Inn
5200 North Lake Drive
Whitefish Bay
Designation Year: 1984
Pandl’s Whitefish Bay Inn is believed to be one of the oldest restaurants in the Milwaukee area operating at its original location. It was first owned by George Bently and called Bently’s Whitefish Bay Inn. This combination tavern-grocery store also served food and was built around 1900 on farmland across from the famous Pabst Whitefish Bay Resort. The Inn ’s patrons were visitors to the nearby Pabst resort and later troops from a local National Guard Armory.
A barn was located at the back of the Inn to accommodate travelers’ teams and wagons. In 1915, John and Anna Pandl bought the Inn with the intention of turning it into a family-style restaurant, even though most of the surrounding area was still farmland. The screened porch was enclosed and turned into the main dining room of Pandl’s Whitefish Bay Inn, while the backrooms were converted into kitchens.
When John Pandl died in 1932, the management of the restaurant was left to his wife, Anna and two sons, George and Jack. The family remodeled the Inn in 1934 but kept the décor fairly simple. When George left to establish his own restaurant in Bayside, Jack took over the management of the Whitefish Bay restaurant, and Anna supervised kitchen operations and lived above the Inn. The restaurant was again remodeled in the late 1960s with wooden panels and beams, and decorated with antiques, Tiffany lamps, and historic photos of the original Inn and its close neighbor the Pabst Whitefish Bay Resort.
